Lip Liner Swatches

I own a grand total of 4 lip liners. One was an Elizabeth Arden PWP with the Leopard Chic box, one is my old Wet 'n Wild #666, which I never liked. The other two are by Essence and were recent purchases because I needed something to finish out the free shipping minimum purchase at Ulta. I like the Taupe well enough, and Honey Bun is what I'd hoped the WNW would have been. Cute Pink isn't bad, it is a little bright. I never cared for drugstore pencils, they are usually hard to apply, but the Essence pencils are as smooth as the Elizabeth Arden, so I'll probably buy more when I order again from Ulta. Anyway, the swatch was photographed with an overhead light and the flash on: