Essence Gel Eyeliner

Why didn't I order that from Ulta? It has 16 Makeupalley reviews and is rated as 100% Would Buy Again. It is only $3.49, and comes in two colors, Midnight in Paris, and London Baby. It gets high marks for staying power, and for being smudge proof. It is 4.8 out of 5 stars. The next time I order from Ulta, I think I'll give this a shot...